My Last (?) Time Fly Fishing

Home » Blog » My Last (?) Time Fly Fishing

 

I know my last blog post left you on the edge of your seat. Today I’m going to answer the question that has doubtlessly been on everyone’s minds: did I catch a fish?

 

Let me tell you, it was getting down to the wire. I’d been out many times with the incredibly patient Claude, to no avail. Not even a bite. Claude’s patience was really commendable as I stubbornly, astoundingly refused to improve. He kept telling me the same things (mend, don’t go so far back, don’t get stuck in the tree, etc) and untangling my fishing line, which got wildly tangled every thirty seconds. But his patience was unsinkable, even as I failed to get so much as a bite, though I tried dry flies and nymphing, different locations and different times of day. Claude’s motto became “We’re gonna catch you a fish!”

 

Except his unsinkable patience began to sink, Titanic-style, when I failed to catch a fish nymphing with about 100 visible whitefish in Warm River. I could tell he was giving up on me. It was my eleventh hour. I begged him to take me out one last time (I have no car. I need assistance.) and he agreed. I knew I had made the honorable Henry’s Fork Foundation blog readers a promise, and I had to keep it.

 

We headed out on the evening of Claude’s last Sunday, the day before this blog post was due. Claude got me set up with a dry fly. I don’t know what kind. I still know nothing. But I set my sights on a batch of trout on the left side of the Warm River, not too far from the bridge. A fire lit within me. I knew it was now or never. I realized it was not only the last time I’d fish with Claude, but maybe the last time I would ever fly fish in my entire life. Time was running out.

 

And I’m happy to say. 

 

I CAUGHT A TROUT!

Me and my perfect trout

 

Is it the tiniest trout you’ve ever seen in your life? Yeah. Maybe. But it’s a trout. And Claude said it was actually kind of impressive to catch a fish that small, because the hooks can’t fit in their tiny mouths. So. I thought it was three inches, but when I said this to Claude, he made a face that let me know it was probably actually closer to two. But a trout’s a trout. I said I’d be holding a trout in this blog post. I didn’t specify what size.

 

I redeemed myself slightly by catching a larger mountain whitefish afterwards, but that doesn’t count since I promised y’all a trout. Claude said the moral of the story was “It’s about the journey, not the destination.” And the journey, from embarrassing myself wildly in front of Claude’s friends on my first time out, my slow but steady (ish) progress on technique, seeing ospreys catch and lose fish, sunsets and deep blue river skies, almost falling in the river a million times, and finally starting to hook some fish, was incredible. But I’m just as happy with the destination. I am very grateful to this tiny fish for falling for my tricks. I’m alright with not having caught a 30-incher. I’m just proud to be able to leave HFF with my promise to catch a trout kept.

 

This might have been my last time fly fishing. I don’t know a single avid fly fisher, though both my brother and my best friend are pretty good with a spinner. So while this won’t be my last time on the water, and it (probably) won’t be the last fish I catch, I can’t say for certain that I’ll ever fly fish again, or that I’ll ever be back on the Henry’s Fork. But one can hope. I’m wrapping up my time here with immense gratitude for everyone that’s helped me grow over the summer, and for one tiny fish.

Facebook
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Recent Posts

General
Jasper Davis

FAQ: Island Park Reservoir Fall 2026 Strategy

This year has brought the Henry’s Fork watershed an extraordinary water-supply challenge. Natural flow is exceptionally low, and Island Park Reservoir is ending the summer at a near-record low level. But there is another important part of this story: we knew these conditions were coming, we planned for them, and water managers are managing the water we have as carefully as possible. HFF is one of the 6 official signatories to the Henry’s Fork Drought

Read More »
General
Jasper Davis

Island Park Reservoir Current Conditions (9/4/26)

Why is Island Park Reservoir getting so low? Simply put, this has been an exceptionally low-water year. There isn’t enough natural flow to meet all of the basin’s needs without drawing down reservoirs. Water managers are working together to deliver water that is legally owed downstream while preserving as much as possible for next year. What should anglers expect below Island Park Dam? As Island Park Reservoir drops too low for the hydropower plant to

Read More »
Water Quality
Christina Morrisett

September 2026 Water Quality Forecast for Island Park

Photo of Island Park Reservoir taken Friday, August 28, 2026 The ingredients for green algae blooms, the primary culprit for turbid water in Island Park, stacked up one after the other earlier this spring. Warm air temperatures. Low streamflow. Long, sunny days. And an ice-free reservoir 30 days earlier than normal. At the Henry’s Fork Foundation, where we swim in water data daily, we braced ourselves for the water quality worst-case scenario: another summer with

Read More »
Water Quality
Christina Morrisett

FAQ: Island Park Reservoir Water Quality

Island Park Reservoir on June 24, 2026 Questions answered in this article: Why are Island Park Reservoir levels so low this year? Is Island Park Reservoir hyper-eutrophic? Are silt and sediment building up behind the dam?   Island Park Reservoir is the center of the Henry’s Fork universe. Reservoir water quality and quantity shape our fisheries, and your fishing experience. But after a warm winter and lower-than-average snowfall, we’ve received a lot of questions about

Read More »